I always dreamed of having this style of shoes so when I saw this in red I just had to have it. I rated it 4 for comfort just because I am not accustomed to walking on 3.25" heels. I am sure that those who are used to using heels will find this comfortable. There is enough room in the toe box and the leather is just heavenly soft and comfortable. Cannot wait to wear this for an upcoming party!

I bought this heel in an 8 in the Brandy color, though it feels to me a bit narrow. This is possibly because of where the sides of the toe box start in relation to my toes. Compared to the Jones, the Jay has a much shorter toe box, and possibly just feels more narrow because the leather toe box of the Jones would naturally stretch a bit as I wear it instead of having a hard line where it starts (if that makes sense). I really like the brandy color, and think it goes nicely dressed up with pencil skirts, but also looks nice with skinny jeans. I have not owned a pair of shoes this color, and with owning a cream pair of heels and a black/cream pair, I think this nicely rounds out most heel situations (though I do want to get a fun 'party' pair).

These are such pretty shoes. I wear a 6 in most dress shoes, and the 6 in these fits me perfectly. They are quite comfy for such a high heel. I highly recommend these. The red/scarlet color is my favorite! The brown/brandy is very versatile.

Cute shoes or I love your shoes is all I hear when wearing these in the color brandy ;) and they don’t lie. These are super cute and comfy. I usually walk a lot certain days and when I do and have these bad boys on, I have no issues. So no complaints there. Like one reviewer said, they’re on thin side so I don’t wear them frequently because I want to keep them forever, lol. They make your feet look sexy too. I love them. I have a different pair in black also from Mz. Mooz In a very similar style and love them both.

I LOVE these heels!! I bought them in several colors and wear them to work daily. They do seem to run narrow in the front. I have bunions which make my foot front wide, while my heel is narrow. Despite this, they fit reasonably well. The "Jones" fits wider in the toe front and is thus a bit more comfy for me, but I really prefer this "Jay" style. Other than the narrow front, they seem to run very true to size. I am a steady size 6 and this shoe fits well on me in a 6. The quality of the leather and soles seems excellent to me.

Pretty with a retro look. Very nice style. Heel is stable. I bought these in the brandy and it is true to the picture. They run a half size small overall. Definitely order up 1/2 size. With the heel, they make your feet look small, so no worries there. Width was as expected; maybe slightly on the narrow side. A bit pricey considering leather and sole are on the thin side. Probably won't want to walk outside much in these as they will wear out quickly. Love they style.